Grace: One nation, not so indivisible - Omaha.com
Published Monday, November 18, 2013 at 12:00 am / Updated at 12:41 pm
Colin Woodard map
Grace: One nation, not so indivisible
THE FAR WEST


High, remote and dry nation shaped more by environment than ethnicity. Became habitable through railroads, mining, dams and irrigation. Residents have felt exploited by outside forces, leaving them resentful and distrustful of corporations and, lately, the federal government.

THE MIDLANDS


Rooted in traditions of English Quakers and German immigrants, this nation believes society should be organized to benefit ordinary people. Prizes the middle class and pluralism. Rejects both top-down government and strong ideology. This makes it a swing nation.

FIRST NATION


Native American groups across North America, including Canada, who generally did not give up their land and retained cultural practices. Now reclaiming its sovereignty, with considerable autonomy in Alaska and a self-governing state in Greenland.

NEW FRANCE


The southernmost parts of Louisiana, along with southern Canada, blend French peasants and the native people the French encountered. Down-to-earth residents are tolerant and consensus-driven, and accept government involvement in the economy.

YANKEEDOM


Puritan founders valued the common good, education and a broad citizen participation in politics and government. More comfortable with government regulation and social projects than other nations.

NEW NETHERLAND


Established by the Dutch, it has a global commercial culture: materialistic, with a profound tolerance for ethnic and religious diversity. A center of publishing, trade, and finance. A magnet for immigrants. Defends public institutions.

TIDEWATER


Built by the younger sons of Southern English gentry, it values authority and tradition more than equality or public participation in politics. In the 18th century, it was the most powerful of American nations, but today it is in decline.

DEEP SOUTH


Developed from a West Indies-style caste system, with democracy for a privileged few and slavery for many. Continues to fight against expanded federal powers, taxes on wealth, and environmental, labor and consumer regulations.

GREATER APPALACHIA


Founders came from war-ravaged Ireland, England and the Scottish lowlands, bringing a culture forged by near-constant danger and upheaval. Values individual liberty and is suspicious of aristocrats and social engineers.

EL NORTE


Oldest, most culturally distinct nation, rooted in the Spanish-American empire. Values independence, self-sufficiency and hard work.

THE LEFT COAST


A hybrid of Yankee utopianism and Appalachian exploration and self-expression, wedged between the Pacific Ocean and mountain ranges. Values shared more with Yankeedom than with Western state neighbors.

Note: In Woodard's world, the southern portion of Florida is part of a separate Spanish Caribbean nation.

Sources: Colin Woodard and
Tufts Magazine

See the full map here.

Drive down my midtown Omaha street and you will see competing symbols in a culture war. In one yard stands a “Defend Marriage” sign. Across the street sits a car bearing the yellow equal sign for gay rights.

You might think the opposing views on Webster Street are just another example of our political polarization — of people taking radically different positions on issues and digging in.

But according to Colin Woodard's take on where Omaha sits, this is a symbol of the city's ability to straddle two political worlds. The Maine writer, whose redrawn map of the United States is attracting attention, sees Omaha as being part of a broader swing region stretching from Kearney to Philadelphia.

Think of us as a geographic and philosophical buffer between the Yankee and Dixie extremes.

He calls us by a familiar name: “The Midlands.”

He ascribes to us these somewhat familiar characteristics: big on the middle class, not so big on ideological purity; want our government organized enough to help ordinary citizens, not so top-down organized we're told what to do.

We are pluralistic. Collectively, we are capable of holding two opposing thoughts, as we do on Webster Street, without going to war over them. When it comes to presidential politics, we are in high demand.

We owe our world view to our roots, says Woodard, and here the English Quakers who settled Pennsylvania and the German farmers who fled feudal land arrangements before the American Revolution get a lot of credit.

The Quakers' belief “in the inner light of man,” he says, makes us more accepting of people who think differently. The Germans' skepticism about the role of government intervention makes us resistant to top-down structure.

If you want to test this theory, look at how we do things in Omaha. We are a Republican mayor and a Democratic-majority City Council. We are concealed-carry permits and legal protections for gays and transgender people. We are a 2nd Congressional District that went blue for Obama in 2008 but still elects Republican Lee Terry cycle after cycle.

We are also the reason Lee Terry has to eke out his wins with, I'm guessing, an ulcer or two. This makes us share more in common with places as far-flung as the City of Brotherly Love than our reliably Republican neighbors to the west, such as North Platte.

Woodard, a reporter for the Portland Press Herald and author of four books, took his pencil and drew a fat line down the middle of the Cornhusker State, splitting east from west.

He blew up the rest of the U.S. map, for that matter, grouping areas according to their linguistic, cultural and political habits.

What results is a far more nuanced portrait of America than you ever get from the talking heads. So forget what you think you know about red America and blue America.

Erase state boundary lines.

Picture instead 11 distinct “nations” with names like Yankeedom, Tidewater and El Norte.

Woodard's book on this subject, called “American Nations: A History of the Eleven Rival Regional Cultures of North America,” came out in 2011.

He drew from that for a recent article published in the Tufts University alumni magazine to explain why America has such high rates of violence compared with other industrialized nations. He looks at assault, the death penalty and mass shootings through the lens of our various worldviews. He explains why gun control might go nowhere given the vast differences between the two most polarized nations: Yankeedom and the Deep South.

Yet he holds hope for how gun control — or any issue on which we're deadlocked — could go somewhere if we understood each other and our differences better and if either entrenched side could make its case for the middle.

The thesis of his work centers on the idea of a “dominant culture” formed hundreds of years ago by the first settlers. This culture has basically stuck, Woodard says, and in some ways is growing more entrenched as people move to places that reinforce their politics.

The culture shapes attitudes about everything from guns to gays and, to a degree, prescribes voting behavior.

Woodard's notion of nations isn't entirely new; other scholars have mapped our national fissures along cultural and historical lines. Some of it boils down to “Duck Dynasty” versus “Mad Men.” America is one big mess of different places and ideas, and state boundary lines don't neatly define that.

Journalist Dante Chinni, who wrote a book called “Our Patchwork Nation,” has produced an even more detailed national self-portrait, defining U.S. counties into 15 different subtypes.

It helps explain why, as my colleague Matthew Hansen wrote recently, conservative eastern Coloradans want to secede from a state they view as increasingly liberal.

It helps explain why, when I lived in Louisiana, natives described that boot as if it were two shoes: North Louisiana, also known as East Texas, and South Louisiana, also known as Cajun Country. The accent, the churches, the food and the people were that different.

Woodard is quick to say that an area's dominant culture doesn't stamp out minority voices. You can have a large minority of blue voters in the reddest of red states and red voters in the bluest of blue states. But the culture that dominates, like it or not, does shape the debate.

I ran this by two local political scientists who, true to form as pluralistic Midlanders, offered differing reactions.

Paul Landow, who teaches urban politics at the University of Nebraska at Omaha, said the United States is not 11 nations, it's two: urban and rural. He rejected the notion that our roots played such a dominant role.

But Kevin Smith of the University of Nebraska-Lincoln said settlers' values, instituted through churches, schools and government, can leave a lasting imprint.

“When I lived in Wisconsin, I thought of myself as a moderate Republican,” Smith said. “When I moved to Nebraska, I was a wild-eyed, left-leaning Democrat.”

His own politics hadn't changed. Just the dominant culture.

Under the Woodard paradigm, this makes sense. Wisconsin belongs to the left-leaning Yankeedom, which is more comfortable with government regulation and social projects. Nebraska is divided between the Midlands, with its wariness about government, and the Far West, where government may not be trusted at all.

When it comes to our individual views, you can drive down any street in America and find people on opposite poles.

The difference in Omaha, it seems, is that we accept that, work with that and come out somewhere in the Great American Middle.

Contact the writer: Erin Grace

erin.grace@owh.com    |   402-444-1136    |  

Erin is a columnist who tries to find interesting stories and get them into the paper. She's drawn to the idea that everyday life offers something extraordinary.

Beau McCoy calls Pete Ricketts a 'convenient conservative' for immigration stance
Police ID body found near 36th, Seward Streets
Agreement reached to end dog racing at Bluffs Run at end of 2015
World champion Crawford's promoter working to have title defense at CenturyLink Center
Hail, strong winds, heavy rain hit south-central Nebraska
Video: Stothert says Crossroads project is 'full speed ahead,' but she won't support bond issue
'Fairly old' human skull found in Mills County
Kelly: Started at a dining room table, Home Instead thriving at 20 with $1B in annual revenue
Omaha crash victim, 19, had touched many lives
Firefighters take on 'fully engulfed barn fire'
Council Bluffs school board approves new district headquarters
Officials announce effort to lure more veterans to Nebraska
SB 132nd Street lane closed
Shane Osborn grabs several endorsements
New public employee pay data: Douglas, Lancaster, Sarpy Counties, plus utilities
Database: How much did Medicare pay your doctor?
Omaha area may get 1 inch of rain tonight
Gov. Heineman vetoes bill to ease restrictions on nurse practitioners
Nebraska banking and finance director to retire
Waitress who served alcohol to teen before fatal crash gets jail time, probation
Owners of exotic dance bar deny prostitution allegations
More Nebraskans are electing to vote early
A day after Ricketts endorsement, Ted Cruz backs Sasse for Senate
Some city streets remain closed
Nebraska's U.S. Senate candidates stick to familiar topics at Omaha forum
< >
COLUMNISTS »
Kelly: Started at a dining room table, Home Instead thriving at 20 with $1B in annual revenue
The idea that Paul Hogan had studied and then hatched at his mother's table was that older people, rather than moving in with relatives or to an assisted-living center, would much prefer to stay home instead.
Breaking Brad: Nebraska GOP candidates unified against naked squirrels
Some of these Nebraska campaigns are tilting pretty far right. At a recent forum, there was a consensus that we need to ban public dancing and clothe naked squirrels in public parks.
Breaking Brad: Inside the mind of a 99-year-old real estate agent
I saw an article about a 99-year-old real estate agent who's still working. “This house is extra special. It has indoor toilets!”
Breaking Brad: Into the claw machine! Florida kid follows Lincoln kid's lead
In Fort Lauderdale, Fla., a child climbed inside a claw machine. Hey, Florida kid: Nobody likes a copycat.
Breaking Brad: Even Chuck Hassebrook's throwing mud!
The Nebraska campaigns have turned so ugly, Democrat Chuck Hassebrook lobbed unfounded accusations at an imaginary opponent.
Deadline Deal thumbnail
7M Grill
Half Off Delicious Comfort Fusion Food & Drinks!
Buy Now
PHOTO GALLERIES »
< >
SPOTLIGHT »
Omaha World-Herald Contests
Enter for a chance to win great prizes.
OWH Store: Buy photos, books and articles
Buy photos, books and articles
Travel Snaps Photo
Going on Vacation? Take the Omaha World-Herald with you and you could the next Travel Snaps winner.
Click here to donate to Goodfellows
The 2011 Goodfellows fund drive provided holiday meals to nearly 5,000 families and their children, and raised more than $500,000 to help families in crisis year round.
WORLD-HERALD ALERTS »
Want to get World-Herald stories sent directly to your home or work computer? Sign up for Omaha.com's News Alerts and you will receive e-mails with the day's top stories.
Can't find what you need? Click here for site map »