For some in oil industry, debate turns to whether Keystone XL pipeline is still needed -
Published Saturday, September 21, 2013 at 1:00 am / Updated at 12:29 am
For some in oil industry, debate turns to whether Keystone XL pipeline is still needed

LINCOLN — With the fate of the Keystone XL pipeline more uncertain than ever, some in the oil industry question whether the highly controversial project is still needed.

The project, which would carry 830,000 barrels of heavy crude through Nebraska on a daily basis, has become the most scrutinized and debated underground pipeline project since it was first proposed five years ago.

Delays have increased speculation that President Barack Obama will reject the pipeline, leading oil producers, shippers and refineries to explore other ways to get oil from western Canada to refineries in the Gulf Coast.

The ramping up of rail transport along with recent announcements of other pipeline projects indicates some investors are hedging their bets on the Keystone XL.

Some argue the pursuit of pipeline alternatives shows that rejecting Keystone XL will only slow the flow of Canadian oil, not stop it.

“I question the naiveté of those who think by shutting down a pipeline, they prevent the development of the oil sands,” said Robert Rapier, a chemical engineer with a background in biofuels who writes a blog about energy trends. “If there isn't Keystone, there are many, many ways of getting it to market.”

Others, including supporters and opponents of the pipeline, say the project remains critically important to the oil industry.

Those working to develop the oil sands region of western Canada point out Keystone XL is furthest down the regulatory road. Pipeline opponents continue to call the pipeline a linchpin that would unleash an environmentally damaging oil resource they refer to as tar sands.

“They are in a real tough spot when it comes to the availability of cheap options to get tar sands to market,” said Anthony Swift, an attorney with the Natural Resources Defense Council.

When TransCanada Corp. officials submitted the application five years ago, they figured the project would be built by now. After all, the company's first Keystone pipeline, with a daily capacity of nearly 600,000 barrels, went in with little fanfare and virtually no opposition.

Objections to Keystone XL emerged over a route that would have taken the pipeline through the environmentally sensitive Nebraska Sand Hills and above the Ogallala Aquifer. Elected officials, landowners and activists raised concerns. Eventually Gov. Dave Heineman told the company to move the route to avoid possible contamination of the aquifer.

In late 2011, the U.S. State Department postponed a decision on the pipeline over the aquifer issue. TransCanada agreed to reroute the project to skirt the Sand Hills.

In the nearly two years since, blocking the Keystone XL has become a major goal of several national environmental groups. They argue the pipeline will further unlock the oil sands region to development and, since that source creates more carbon pollution than conventional crude, contribute significantly to climate change.

The application for the pipeline has since undergone reviews by Nebraska's environmental agency and the State Department. The reviews found the project presented no major threats to land, water or global temperatures.

Those conclusions, however are disputed by the U.S. Environmental Protection Agency and many environmentalists.

Currently, the State Department is sorting through more than 1 million comments received on the preliminary environmental review. The president is not expected to reach a decision until late this year or early next year.

The delays and debate have not diminished the importance of Keystone XL to the petroleum industry, said Greg Stringham, vice president of the Canadian Association of Petroleum Producers.

“It is still very strategic for Canada to be able to access the Gulf Coast refineries,” he said.

Stringham acknowledged, however, that investors and shippers aren't standing by while the project remains in limbo. The rail industry, in particular, appears to be taking advantage of the delay.

By some projections, railroads could load up to 800,000 barrels of heavy Canadian crude daily by 2015. That's nearly as much oil as would move through Keystone XL.

Two years ago, for example, rail transported about 10,000 barrels daily of diluted bitumen, the type of heavy oil mined in Canada. Now, railroads load close to 200,000 barrels daily, Stringham said.

The American Association of Railroads views pipelines and railroads as safe and sees a role for both in transporting crude.

The growth of oil-by-rail hasn't been without criticism. The practice is being more closely scrutinized since July, when railcars loaded with North Dakota crude derailed and exploded, killing 47 people in a small town in Quebec.

In addition, it costs significantly more to ship oil by train than by pipeline.

But rail provides more flexibility for producers to get their oil to market. And existing rail lines do not need the president's approval to bring Canadian oil into the U.S.

While most of the oil in the Keystone XL would flow from Canada, about 100,000 barrels of its daily volume would originate in the booming oil fields of North Dakota and Montana. But the head of one of the biggest oil producers in North Dakota has said Keystone XL has become all but irrelevant.

Harold Hamm, CEO of Continental Resources, recently told the National Journal that rail transportation and other pipelines have emerged to ship North Dakota's oil. And more are planned.

“It's not critical any longer,” Hamm said of Keystone XL. “They just waited too long. The industry is very innovative, and it finds other ways of doing it and other routes.”

Shawn Howard, spokesman for TransCanada Corp., said Keystone XL remains just as necessary today as when it was first proposed in 2008. Thursday marked the fifth anniversary of its application for a presidential permit.

The company has signed contracts with oil producers and refiners that will fill the pipeline near capacity if it is built, he said.

Howard called the use of rail a “short-term response” because of its higher costs. And he pointed out that federal studies have shown pipelines to be the safest transportation method for liquid fuels.

But a pipeline can't deliver oil until it's built, said Bill Day, spokesman for Valero Energy Corp., which operates Gulf Coast refineries capable of processing bitumen. The company had a contract with Keystone XL, but it has expired, he said.

Valero is currently upgrading some Louisiana refinery units to receive Canadian oil via rail and other pipeline proposals that would not need a presidential permit.

“One way or another, the oil will find its way to the Gulf Coast or find its way to other countries,” Day said.

Meanwhile, pipeline companies aren't surrendering to rail. TransCanada recently proposed a different pipeline that would move 1.1 million barrels per day to eastern Canada, therefore avoiding American politics. Others have been proposed to take oil to Canada's West Coast, and pipeline builder Enbridge has announced a project that would move more Canadian oil out of Illinois to the Gulf.

Environmental groups and others don't buy that argument. They cite recent analysis by major investment firms that predict if Keystone XL fails to win approval, development of the Canadian oil sands could stagnate.

All parties with a stake in the fight will continue to closely follow Keystone XL, said pipeline opponent Jane Kleeb, executive director of Bold Nebraska.

“If Keystone XL is denied, it could have a domino effect on other pipelines of a similar nature,” she said. “If they lose this pipeline, it puts doubt on their investment.”

Contact the writer: Joe Duggan    |  

Joe works in the Lincoln bureau, where he helps cover state government, the Legislature, state Supreme Court and southeast Nebraska.

Waitress who served alcohol to teen before fatal crash gets jail time, probation
Lori Jenkins, charged as accessory in 4 murders, waives speedy trial
Iowa State servers hacked, nearly 30,000 SSNs at risk
New public employee pay data: Douglas, Lancaster, Sarpy Counties, plus utilities
2nd District House race: After 8 terms, Lee Terry knows how D.C. works — and doesn't
Bellevue man is killed at Minnesota dance hall after South Sudanese basketball tourney
Spring corn planting still sputters in Nebraska, Iowa, other key states
Nebraska banking and finance director to retire
19-year-old killed in one-vehicle crash at 72nd & Shirley
Gov. Heineman vetoes bill to ease restrictions on nurse practitioners
U.S. Senate race: State Auditor Mike Foley defends Shane Osborn against ad campaign
Public defender to represent Nikko Jenkins in sentencing
Mid-America Center on track for lower operating loss
Bluffs City Council approves dozens of new numbered street lights
National Law Enforcement Memorial Week set for May
Ted Cruz backs Pete Ricketts' campaign for governor
Omahan charged with 5th-offense DUI after street race causes rollover
2 blocks of Grover Street closed
Safety board report blames pilot error in 2013 crash that killed UNO student, passenger
Omaha man accused in shooting ordered held on $75,000 bail
2 men charged with conspiracy to distribute meth held on $1 million bail each
La Vista plans meeting on sales tax proposal, 84th Street redevelopment
6-mile stretch of Highway 75 is the road not taken
Database: How much did Medicare pay your doctor?
Millard school board bans e-cigarettes from all district properties, events
< >
Breaking Brad: Into the claw machine! Florida kid follows Lincoln kid's lead
In Fort Lauderdale, Fla., a child climbed inside a claw machine. Hey, Florida kid: Nobody likes a copycat.
Breaking Brad: Even Chuck Hassebrook's throwing mud!
The Nebraska campaigns have turned so ugly, Democrat Chuck Hassebrook lobbed unfounded accusations at an imaginary opponent.
Breaking Brad: Kraft wiener recall is business opportunity for TD Ameritrade Park
Instead of returning the wieners, TD Ameritrade Park is calling them "cheese dogs" and charging double.
Breaking Brad: Photos with the Easter Bunny are so 2010
In a sign of the times, most kids ran out of patience waiting for a photo with the Easter Bunny at the mall, just snapped a selfie and went home.
Kelly: 70 years after a deadly D-Day rehearsal, Omahan, WWII vet will return to Europe
A World War II veteran from Omaha will return this week to Europe to commemorate a tragedy in the run-up to D-Day.
Deadline Deal thumbnail
Steam-A-Way Carpet Cleaning
$50 for 3 rooms and a Hallway up to 600 square feet
Buy Now
< >
Omaha World-Herald Contests
Enter for a chance to win great prizes.
OWH Store: Buy photos, books and articles
Buy photos, books and articles
Travel Snaps Photo
Going on Vacation? Take the Omaha World-Herald with you and you could the next Travel Snaps winner.
Click here to donate to Goodfellows
The 2011 Goodfellows fund drive provided holiday meals to nearly 5,000 families and their children, and raised more than $500,000 to help families in crisis year round.
Want to get World-Herald stories sent directly to your home or work computer? Sign up for's News Alerts and you will receive e-mails with the day's top stories.
Can't find what you need? Click here for site map »