Failure in Omaha haunted Garcia throughout career -
Published Wednesday, July 17, 2013 at 12:01 am / Updated at 5:35 pm
Failure in Omaha haunted Garcia throughout career

Documents: Indiana medical licensing board material related to Garcia's request for a license

Photos: More images related to the cases


In the fall of 2012, Dr. Roger Brumback may have unwittingly sealed his fate.

At that time, Brumback wrote a letter to the Indiana medical licensing board, explaining why former Creighton University pathology resident Dr. Anthony J. Garcia was fired in 2001.

Six months later, Brumback and his wife, Mary, were found dead in their Omaha home.

A similar letter, written in February 2008, to Louisiana medical officials may have sealed the fate of house cleaner Shirlee Sherman and 11-year-old Thomas Hunter, who were killed about a month later.

The boy's father, Dr. William Hunter, worked with Brumback at Creighton University's pathology department and had a hand in Garcia's dismissal.

Garcia was arrested Monday in connection with the four unsolved murders, committed over a span of five years, that sent tremors of fear through Creighton's medical community.

The latest in the case

Dr. Anthony J. Garcia has been charged with four counts of first-degree murder in connection with the Omaha killings. He is scheduled to appear in court at 11:30 a.m. today at the Union County Courthouse in Jonesboro, Ill.

Garcia is being represented by a legal team that includes Robert M. Motta II and his wife, Alison H. Motta, and Motta's father, Robert M. Motta. The senior Motta defended serial killer John Wayne Gacy, who was convicted of the sexual assault and murder of 33 teenage boys and young men. Gacy was executed for his crimes in 1994.

Robert M. Motta II said late Tuesday afternoon that he and his co-counsel were en route to Jonesboro and have not been able to meet with Garcia or review the case file. Motta said a decision on whether to fight extradition may not be made until just prior to or during today's hearing.

Garcia made a first appearance in Union County Circuit Court on Tuesday morning. Presiding Circuit Judge Mark Boie read the Nebraska charges against Garcia, who walked into the courtroom in a gray-striped jail jumpsuit and chains.
Garcia told the judge he had not spoken with an attorney. The judge said he would not proceed with the question of sending Garcia to Omaha until Garcia could consult with a lawyer.
Garcia is being held at the Jackson County Jail in Murphysboro, Ill.

Task force investigators reportedly were in Garcia's hometown of Walnut, Calif., and at an Indiana federal prison where Garcia worked as a contract physician.

Besides the Nebraska murder charges, Garcia faces charges of drunken driving and unlawful use of a weapon stemming from his arrest Monday in Union County, Ill. Authorities said Garcia appeared to be intoxicated and had a .45-caliber handgun.

Compiled by World-Herald staff writers Maggie O'Brien, Todd Cooper, Jeanne Hauser and Lizzie Johnson, as well as Caleb Hale of the Southern Illinoisan in Carbondale, Ill.

Officials say the former federal prison doctor was motivated by revenge because he believed his dismissal at Creighton had cast a pall over his medical career.

Alison Motta of Aurora, Ill., a lawyer hired by Garcia's family, said Tuesday that the family is “sure this is a mix-up.”

“They fully support him and are certain this is not what it appears,” Motta told The World-Herald.

Garcia, who worked in Chicago, is expected to make his second court appearance at 11:30 a.m. today in Jonesboro, Ill. It is not known whether he will fight extradition to Nebraska. Such fights within the United States are typically futile.

Garcia's former boss in Chicago, Dr. Benjamin Toh, described him Tuesday as a good employee who was well liked by their patients, but who was private and would dodge questions about his personal life.

“Any prying, and you would get an abstract, vague, nondescript answer,” said Toh.

The Indiana medical licensing board on Tuesday released a slew of documents that cast some light on Garcia's residency woes and gave a possible deadly timeline for why he may have returned to Omaha.

Garcia, who once worked as a contracted prison doctor at a federal penitentiary in Terre Haute, Ind., had applied for a medical license in that state in 2008. As a part of that application process, the board sought information from Creighton and other medical facilities where Garcia had worked.

In a 2012 letter to the medical board, Brumback explained that Garcia was fired for “unprofessional behavior toward a fellow resident.” Other documents said Garcia attempted to sabotage a fellow resident by calling the resident's wife while he was taking an exam and demanding that he return to work.

“This (the call) resulted in considerable anxiety and distress for the wife and the resident at a time when the resident was attempting to pass a high-stakes examination which would ultimately determine whether or not he could continue in the residency program,” according to a termination letter sent to Garcia by Creighton.

That letter was signed by Dr. Walter J. O'Donohue Jr., an associate dean at Creighton University. O'Donohue died of a genetic disease in 2002.

The documents also provide another possible motive for the earlier slayings of 11-year-old Thomas Hunter and Shirlee Sherman.

The two were stabbed to death in March 2008, just a month after the Louisiana State Board of Medical Examiners denied Garcia a license based in large part on his termination from Creighton, according to the documents.

Overall, the documents indicate that Garcia's troubles as a resident made it difficult for him to become licensed in other states — except Illinois, which granted Garcia a license in 2003.

Garcia was fired from three residency programs. At the Bassett St. Elizabeth Medical Center residency program in Utica, N.Y., Garcia was fired after he yelled at a radiology technician.

The New York board of medical conduct sent Garcia a letter, saying that his conduct in the residency raised concerns and that if he applied for a license in New York, his application would be “flagged” for additional scrutiny.

“Our reviewer expressed concern regarding your behavior during your entire residency at Bassett and felt that your conduct left serious doubt as to your future ability to successfully practice medicine within acceptable standards,” the New York board wrote in a 2001 letter to Garcia.

Garcia said in a rebuttal letter that he resigned from Bassett after he was suspended.

“On the last month I was there, I was suspended for yelling at a radiology technician. I subsequently resigned my position because I felt I was being treated unfairly,” Garcia wrote in a letter that was a part of his Indiana application.

After New York, Garcia was accepted at Creighton. He lasted only about a year before he was fired.

Garcia also took issue with his firing at Creighton, saying the only thing he did wrong was to call a fellow pathology resident and tell him that his vacation had not been approved.

He then was accepted at the University of Illinois at Chicago family residency program but left after about two years, he said, due to “poor health/migraine headaches.”

His last and final residency program was in psychiatry at Louisiana State University Medical Center in Shreveport. He lasted seven months before he was dismissed.

It is believed Garcia grew up in the wealthy California community of Walnut, east of Los Angeles. He attended undergraduate college at Mt. San Antonio College in Walnut and has used a Walnut home as his mailing address for years, including when he applied for his Indiana medical license.

A man who answered the telephone at the home, valued at more than $650,000, declined to comment Tuesday. “I don't have to talk to you,” he said, before hanging up.

Shortly after he was granted a medical license in Illinois, Garcia appeared to be beset by both medical and financial problems.

In 2004, he apparently returned home to Walnut, where he filed for bankruptcy. A big part of his debt was medical bills. In his bankruptcy documents, Garcia said he was unemployed.

In about 2009, he returned to Chicago with only his black Pontiac convertible stuffed with his belongings. He soon found a job at the clinic Visiting Physicians, which was owned by Toh.

Garcia was hired to go into the homes of elderly patients on Medicare and perform medical services.

When he first got to Chicago, Garcia did not have a place to live or any furniture. Toh rented him a furnished room until he eventually moved into an apartment in the tony Hyde Park area.

Toh recalls that he asked Garcia in the job interview about a fellowship or residency that he had started but not finished at the University of Illinois.

Toh also was curious about how Garcia seemed to be an experienced doctor even though he hadn't practiced in more than five years. He also wondered how he could afford such nice things with no medical salary.

Garcia never really answered those questions, though he did imply that he had some kind of personal crisis or breakdown.

Garcia eventually moved on in less than a year. At one point he had mentioned that he was contracting with another clinic, Toh said.

“Not to make light of the matter,” Toh said of the killings, “but when I heard about it I thought, thank God I didn't fire him.”

Online records linked Garcia with a similar clinic about 20 minutes south of Toh's. But a man who works there said the office is no longer a clinic and doesn't employ doctors. He said he had not heard of Garcia.

World-Herald staff writer Maggie O'Brien contributed to this report.

Contact the writer: Robynn Tysver    |   402-444-1309    |  

Robynn is's elections writer. She's covered presidential politics in Iowa's caucuses, and gubernatorial and Senate races in Nebraska.

Omaha police investigate two nonfatal shootings
Easter Sunday temperatures climb into 80s in Omaha area
City Council to vote on adding Bluffs pedestrian safety lights
Sole big donor to Beau McCoy says he expects nothing in return
Convicted killer Nikko Jenkins might await his sentence in prison
Kelly: 70 years after a deadly D-Day rehearsal, Omahan, WWII vet will return to Europe
Midlands runners ready for Boston Marathon
Families from area shelters treated to meal at Old Chicago
Firefighters battle brush fire near Fontenelle Forest
Sioux City riverboat casino prepares to close, still hoping to be saved
Omaha high schoolers to help canvass for Heartland 2050
Mizzou alumni aim to attract veterinary students to Henry Doorly Zoo
Grant ensures that Sioux City can start building children's museum
Party looks to 'nudge' women into public office in Iowa
For birthday, Brownell-Talbot student opts to give, not get
Two taken to hospital after fire at Benson home
Grace: Pipe organ concert a tribute to couple's enduring love
Omaha-area jails and ERs new front line in battling mental illness
Civil rights hearing to consider voting policies in Midwest
17 senators in Nebraska Legislature hit their (term) limits
It's a pursuit of pastel at Spring Lake Park's Easter egg hunt
Financial picture improving for city-owned Mid-America Center
No injuries after fire at midtown's old Mercer Mansion
29-year-old Omahan arrested for 22nd time in Lincoln
Police: Slaying of woman in Ralston apartment likely over drugs
< >
Kelly: 70 years after a deadly D-Day rehearsal, Omahan, WWII vet will return to Europe
A World War II veteran from Omaha will return this week to Europe to commemorate a tragedy in the run-up to D-Day.
Dickson’s Week in Review, April 13-19
On Twitter some guy tweeted that the spring game isn’t taken as seriously as a regular-season contest. What was your first clue? When the head coach entered waving a cat aloft?
Kelly: A California university president returns to her Nebraska roots on Ivy Day
The main speaker at today's Ivy Day celebration at the University of Nebraska-Lincoln is a college president who grew up roping calves and earned her Ph.D. at the prestigious Oxford University in England.
Breaking Brad: Stuck in a claw machine? You get no Easter candy
I know of one kid in Lincoln who will be receiving a lump of coal from the Easter Bunny, just as soon as he's extricated from that bowling alley claw machine.
Breaking Brad: Mountain lion season's over, but the bunny's fair game!
Thursday was the last day of a Nebraska Legislature session. Before leaving town, legislators passed a bill to hold a lottery to hunt the Easter Bunny.
Deadline Deal thumbnail
The Jaipur in Rockbrook Village
Half Off Fine Indian Cuisine & Drinks! $15 for Dinner, or $7 for Lunch
Buy Now
< >
Omaha World-Herald Contests
Enter for a chance to win great prizes.
OWH Store: Buy photos, books and articles
Buy photos, books and articles
Travel Snaps Photo
Going on Vacation? Take the Omaha World-Herald with you and you could the next Travel Snaps winner.
Click here to donate to Goodfellows
The 2011 Goodfellows fund drive provided holiday meals to nearly 5,000 families and their children, and raised more than $500,000 to help families in crisis year round.
Want to get World-Herald stories sent directly to your home or work computer? Sign up for's News Alerts and you will receive e-mails with the day's top stories.
Can't find what you need? Click here for site map »