Final pipeline hearing pits jobs against environment -
Published Friday, April 19, 2013 at 12:00 am / Updated at 8:00 am
Final pipeline hearing pits jobs against environment

GRAND ISLAND, Neb. — A pipeline builder stood among pipeline fighters Thursday and tried his best to persuade the State Department to approve the controversial Keystone XL crude oil pipeline.

Chad Gilbert, a welder from Mancos, Colo., said the track record proves that pipelines move oil more safely than trucks, trains or ships.

He testified Thursday during the final public hearing on a proposal to transport 830,000 barrels of tar-sands crude daily from western Canada to refineries on the Texas Gulf Coast. Part of the route would cross Nebraska.

“Yes, we are real people seeking real work,” said Gilbert, representing a pipeline builders union with members in Nebraska. “If that's not in the national interest, what is?”

As he spoke, many in the crowd held up black armbands printed with the words, “pipeline fighter.” During such displays, it was clear that pipeline opponents outnumbered the supporters.

When it was their turn at the microphone, the opponents argued that the pipeline threatens to contaminate the water that supports life, livestock and livelihoods.

“We Nebraskans will bear the risk forever,” said Meghan Hammond, 25, who farms family land in York County that would be crossed by the underground pipeline.

And so, the final public debate in Grand Island sounded much like other debates over the Keystone XL that have come before. It boiled down to jobs and energy security versus private property rights and environmental protection.

The 1,700-mile route includes 274 miles through Nebraska.

Despite hazardous wintry driving conditions, hundreds showed up at the Heartland Events Center to comment on the State Department's draft environmental assessment of the pipeline.

Although the department did not take a head count as people passed through a metal detector at the entrance, most of the 700 floor seats were quickly filled, along with scores of additional seats on the sides of the arena.

The hearing lasted 10½ hours, and about 200 people testified. Their input will be added to the 807,000 comments that have already been submitted on the controversial project.

Not all testifiers gave speeches. One speaker offered poetry, one performed a Native American prayer song and another sang an anti-pipeline ode to the melody of “Blowin' in the Wind.”

Dressed as a polar bear, John Babban of Omaha takes a break during a anti-pipeline press conference in the Fonner Park Cafe on Thursday before a U.S. State Department public hearing on the Keystone XL Pipeline at the Heartland Events Center in Grand Island. BARRETT STINSON/WORLD-HERALD NEWS SERVICE

Another pipeline opponent walked through the arena in a polar bear suit, alluding to a contention by environmentalists that further development of Canada's tar-sands region will contribute substantially to greenhouse gas emissions.

But there were also moments marked by raised voices, frustration and palpable anger, especially among those who sense that pipeline approval is a foregone conclusion — given the lack of environmental red flags raised by the State Department's March 1 draft assessment.

“I'm going to lay down in front of them damn Caterpillars and let them run me over to keep this from being built,” said Ernie Fellows of Keya Paha County in northern Nebraska.

The exercise felt like déjà vu for many participants, given that the State Department gathered extensive public comments on the proposal in 2010 and 2011.

But the department halted the review process in late 2011, citing concerns that the pipeline posed a threat to the fragile soils and high water tables of the Nebraska Sand Hills.

Under executive order, the State Department must determine if the project is in the national interest because it crosses an international border.

TransCanada Corp., the company that wants to build the pipeline, moved the route last year to avoid the Sand Hills. Gov. Dave Heineman approved the rerouting in January, after the Nebraska Department of Environmental Quality determined that groundwater contamination from any spills would most likely be local rather than regional.

Three landowners have since filed a lawsuit challenging the constitutionality of the law that allowed the governor's approval.

During Thursday's hearing, several opponents called the state and federal environmental reviews incomplete because they didn't model what a “worst-case scenario” spill could do to groundwater, rivers or lakes.

They also criticized the agencies for contracting with private consultants who had formerly worked for the oil industry. One of the State Department's consultants worked for TransCanada in the past.

“It seems your environmental impact statement has as many holes as these pipelines that keep leaking in the news today,” said Jim Tarnick, a farmer and rancher near Fullerton.

Tom Gross, director of pipeline and gas distribution with the pipefitters, plumbers and steamfitters union, speaks in favor of the Keystone XL pipeline AP PHOTO/NATI HARNIK

Kerri-Ann Jones, assistant secretary of state in charge of the federal pipeline review, said the department screens consultants for possible conflicts of interests.

She said there are a relatively small number of private professionals in the field, so it's not uncommon for them to have worked for the petroleum industry in the past.

“We don't feel the report is compromised in any way,” she said.

The public comment period on the draft environmental report closes Monday.

After that, the department will prepare a final report and submit it to eight federal agencies, which will have up to 90 days to provide their input. Then Secretary of State John Kerry will make a decision on the permit.

Thursday's hearing was the only one the department scheduled along the route of the pipeline, which crosses parts of six states.

Among those testifying in support were state and local economic development officials and a slew of representatives from the petroleum industry. They repeated common themes that the nation needs the jobs and the oil from a friendly trade partner.

But perhaps the most common testifiers were the Nebraska landowners who said the pipeline route crosses their property.

Bonny Kilmurry, one such landowner in Holt County, said the whole process has made her feel powerless and abandoned.

“When this man-made pipeline fails, who will clean our water?” she asked.

Contact the writer: 402-473-9587,

Contact the writer: Joe Duggan    |  

Joe works in the Lincoln bureau, where he helps cover state government, the Legislature, state Supreme Court and southeast Nebraska.

More Nebraskans are electing to vote early
Nebraska's U.S. Senate candidates stick to familiar topics at Omaha forum
Kelly: Started at a dining room table, Home Instead thriving at 20 with $1B in annual revenue
8% of alcohol sellers checked in Omaha area last week sold booze to minors
OPS bus, SUV collide; no students onboard at the time
Waitress who served alcohol to teen before fatal crash gets jail time, probation
Lori Jenkins, charged as accessory in 4 murders, waives speedy trial
Iowa State servers hacked, nearly 30,000 SSNs at risk
New public employee pay data: Douglas, Lancaster, Sarpy Counties, plus utilities
2nd District House race: After 8 terms, Lee Terry knows how D.C. works — and doesn't
Bellevue man is killed at Minnesota dance hall after South Sudanese basketball tourney
Spring corn planting still sputters in Nebraska, Iowa, other key states
Nebraska banking and finance director to retire
19-year-old killed in one-vehicle crash at 72nd & Shirley
Gov. Heineman vetoes bill to ease restrictions on nurse practitioners
U.S. Senate race: State Auditor Mike Foley defends Shane Osborn against ad campaign
Public defender to represent Nikko Jenkins in sentencing
Mid-America Center on track for lower operating loss
Bluffs City Council approves dozens of new numbered street lights
National Law Enforcement Memorial Week set for May
Ted Cruz backs Pete Ricketts' campaign for governor
Omahan charged with 5th-offense DUI after street race causes rollover
2 blocks of Grover Street closed
Safety board report blames pilot error in 2013 crash that killed UNO student, passenger
Omaha man accused in shooting ordered held on $75,000 bail
< >
Kelly: Started at a dining room table, Home Instead thriving at 20 with $1B in annual revenue
The idea that Paul Hogan had studied and then hatched at his mother's table was that older people, rather than moving in with relatives or to an assisted-living center, would much prefer to stay home instead.
Breaking Brad: Into the claw machine! Florida kid follows Lincoln kid's lead
In Fort Lauderdale, Fla., a child climbed inside a claw machine. Hey, Florida kid: Nobody likes a copycat.
Breaking Brad: Even Chuck Hassebrook's throwing mud!
The Nebraska campaigns have turned so ugly, Democrat Chuck Hassebrook lobbed unfounded accusations at an imaginary opponent.
Breaking Brad: Kraft wiener recall is business opportunity for TD Ameritrade Park
Instead of returning the wieners, TD Ameritrade Park is calling them "cheese dogs" and charging double.
Breaking Brad: Photos with the Easter Bunny are so 2010
In a sign of the times, most kids ran out of patience waiting for a photo with the Easter Bunny at the mall, just snapped a selfie and went home.
Deadline Deal thumbnail
Tokyo Sushi
$5 for $10 or $10 for $20 toward All-You-Can-Eat Sushi Purchase
Buy Now
< >
Omaha World-Herald Contests
Enter for a chance to win great prizes.
OWH Store: Buy photos, books and articles
Buy photos, books and articles
Travel Snaps Photo
Going on Vacation? Take the Omaha World-Herald with you and you could the next Travel Snaps winner.
Click here to donate to Goodfellows
The 2011 Goodfellows fund drive provided holiday meals to nearly 5,000 families and their children, and raised more than $500,000 to help families in crisis year round.
Want to get World-Herald stories sent directly to your home or work computer? Sign up for's News Alerts and you will receive e-mails with the day's top stories.
Can't find what you need? Click here for site map »